-
Governance advisory
We guide boards and management teams in frameworks, team processes and leadership dynamics to deliver sustainable value.
-
Financial services advisory
Get market-driven expertise to achieve your goals in banking, insurance, capital markets, and investment management.
-
Business risk services
Our market-driven expertise helps firms keep growing and manage risk in an evolving regulatory landscape.
-
Risk
Meet risks with confidence and transform your business – we support you to manage risk and deliver on your goals.
-
Economic consulting
Bespoke guidance grounded in complex economic theory and practical sector insight to help you make the right decisions.
-
Government and public sector
Experience and expertise in delivering quality public sector advisory and audits.
-
Business consulting
Partnering with you to deliver sustainable business change that helps you realise your ambitions.
-
Transaction advisory services
Whether buying or selling, we help you get the deal done with our comprehensive range of transaction advisory services.
-
Financial accounting advisory services (FAAS)
Our FAAS team can support your finance function with the flexible resource they need to get results.
-
Corporate finance advisory
Building a business is never easy. We help you maximise the value of your business and find the right option.
-
Valuations
Help to understand or support the valuation of a business or asset.
-
Insolvency and global asset recovery
We provide asset tracing and seamless cross-border global recovery for clients.
-
Forensic and investigation services
Market-driven expertise in investigations, dispute resolution and digital forensics.
-
Restructuring
Our restructuring team help lenders, investors and management navigate contingency plans, restructuring and insolvency.
-
Transformation consulting
Is business transformation a priority for your organisation? Our expert insight and guidance can help you achieve it.
-
Pensions assurance
A tailored service that responds to evolving risks and regulations.
-
Accounting services
Optimise your growth with expert accounting services. Contact us today.
-
Royalty and intellectual property (IP) audits
Enhance IP asset protection with our royalty and IP audit services. Expertise in licensing, revenue detection, and compliance improvements.
-
Business consulting
Partnering with you to deliver sustainable business change that helps you realise your ambitions.
-
Corporate Simplification
Release value, reduce compliance complexity, and improve tax efficiency by streamlining your group structure.
-
Economic consulting
Bespoke guidance grounded in complex economic theory and practical sector insight to help you make the right decisions.
-
Governance advisory
We guide boards and management teams in frameworks, team processes and leadership dynamics to deliver sustainable value.
-
International
Unlock global opportunities with our local expertise and worldwide reach.
-
People advisory
Driving business performance through people strategy and culture.
-
Strategy Group
Successful business strategy is rooted in a clear understanding of the market, customer segmentation and how purchase decisions vary.
-
Respond: Data breach, incident response and computer forensics
Are you prepared for a cyber failure? We can help you avoid data breaches and offer support if the worst happens.
-
Comply: Cyber security regulation and compliance
Cyber security regulation and compliance is constantly evolving. Our team can support you through the digital landscape.
-
Protect: Cyber security strategy, testing and risk assessment
Cyber security threats are constantly evolving. We’ll work with you to develop and test robust people, process and technology defences to protect your data and information assets.
-
Corporate finance advisory
Building a business is never easy. We help you maximise the value of your business and find the right option.
-
Debt advisory
Working with borrowers and private equity financial sponsors on raising and refinancing debt. We can help you find the right lender and type of debt products.
-
Financial accounting advisory services (FAAS)
Our FAAS team can support your finance function with the flexible resource they need to get results.
-
Financial modelling services
Financial modelling that helps you wrestle with your most pressing business decisions.
-
Operational deal services
Enabling transaction goals through due diligence, integration, separation, and other complex change.
-
Our credentials
Search our transactions to see our experience in your sector and explore the deals advisory services we've delivered.
-
Transaction advisory services
Whether buying or selling, we help you get the deal done with our comprehensive range of transaction advisory services.
-
Valuations
Help to understand or support the valuation of a business or asset.
-
The ESG agenda
Shape your ESG agenda by identifying the right metrics, sustainable development and potential business value impact.
-
ESG driven business transition
Whatever your ESG strategy, we can support your organisation as it evolves while maximising efficiency and profitability.
-
ESG programme and change management
Do you have the right capabilities to drive the delivery of your ESG strategy to realise your targets?
-
ESG risk management
You must protect, comply, understand and influence to successfully manage the risk involved with ESG issues. We can help.
-
ESG strategy, risk and opportunity identification
We can help you clearly define your ESG Strategy, with the risks and opportunities identified and managed.
-
Create value through effective ESG communication
Building trust and engagement with your stakeholders on your ESG strategy.
-
ESG metrics, targets and disclosures
The pressure to report your ESG progress is growing. Do your targets measure up?
-
ESG governance, leadership and culture framework
Make the most of ESG opportunities by effectively embedding your strategy across your organisation.
-
ESG and non-financial assurance
Support your board to be confident in supplying robust information that withstands scrutiny.
-
Actuarial and insurance consulting
We consult extensively to the life insurance, general insurance, health insurance and pensions sectors.
-
Business risk services
Our market-driven expertise helps firms keep growing and manage risk in an evolving regulatory landscape.
-
Financial crime
Helping you fight financial crime in a constantly changing environment
-
Financial services business consulting
Leverage our diverse capabilities to manage challenges and take opportunities: from assurance to transformation
-
Financial services tax
Helping financial services firms navigate the global financial services and funds tax landscape.
-
Regulatory and compliance
Providing an exceptional level of regulatory and compliance to firms across the financial services industry.
-
Corporate intelligence
Corporate intelligence often involves cross-border complexities. Our experienced team can offer support.
-
Litigation support
Industry-wide litigation support and investigation services for lawyers and law firms.
-
Disputes advisory
Advising on quantum, accounting and financial issues in commercial disputes.
-
Forensic investigations and special situations
Do you need clarity in an uncertain situation? If you're accused of wrongdoing we can help you get the facts right.
-
Forensic data analytics
Our forensic data analytics team are helping businesses sift the truth from their data. See how we can help your firm.
-
Monitoring trustee and competition services
Monitoring trustee services to competition, financial and regulatory bodies.
-
Financial crime
Supporting your fight against financial crime in an ever-changing environment
-
Public sector advisory
To deliver excellent public services, local and central government need specialist support.
-
Public sector consulting
Helping public sector organisations maintain oversight of services and understand what's happening on the ground.
-
Public sector audit and assurance
As a leading UK auditor, we have unparalleled insights into the risks, challenges and opportunities that you face.
-
Contentious estates and family disputes
We manage complex and sensitive disputes through to resolution.
-
Digital Asset Recovery
Get guidance and technical expertise on digital finance and cryptoasset recovery from our dedicated crypto hub.
-
Grant Thornton Offshore
Grant Thornton Offshore is our one-stop global solution for insolvency, asset recovery, restructuring and forensics services.
-
Insolvency Act Portal
Case information and published reports on insolvency cases handled by Grant Thornton UK LLP.
-
Litigation support
Industry-wide litigation support and investigation services for lawyers and law firms.
-
Personal insolvency
We can support you to maximise personal insolvency recovery and seek appropriate debt relief.
-
South Asia business group
Supporting your growth in the UK-India economic corridor and beyond.
-
US business group
Optimise your trans-Atlantic operations with local knowledge and global reach.
-
Japan business group
Bridging the commercial and cultural divide and supporting your ambitions across Japan and the UK.
-
Africa business group
Connecting you to the right local teams in the UK, Africa, and the relevant offshore centres.
-
China-Britain business group
Supporting your operations across the China – UK economic corridor.
-
Contingency planning and administrations
In times of financial difficulty, it is vital that directors explore all the options that are available to them, including having a robust ‘Plan B’.
-
Corporate restructuring
Corporate restructuring can be a difficult time. Let our team make the process simple and as stress-free as possible.
-
Creditor and lender advisory
Whether you're a creditor or lender, complex restructurings depend on pragmatic commercial advice
-
Debt advisory
Our debt advisory team can find the right lender to help you in restructuring. Find out how our experts can support you.
-
Financial services restructuring and insolvency
Financial services restructuring and insolvency is a competitive marketplace. Our team can help you navigate this space.
-
Pensions advisory services
DB pension-schemes need a balanced approach that manages risk for trustees and sponsors in an uncertain economy.
-
Restructuring and insolvency tax
Tax will often be crucial in a plan to restructure a distressed business. Our team can guide you through the process.
-
Restructuring Plans
Market leading experience in advising companies and creditors in Restructuring Plan processes.
-
Controls advisory
Build a robust internal control environment in a changing world.
-
Data assurance and analytics
Enhancing your data processes, tools and internal capabilities to help you make decisions on managing risk and controls.
-
Enterprise risk management
Understand and embrace enterprise risk management – we help you develop and connect risk thinking to your objectives.
-
Internal audit services
Internal audit services that deliver the value and impact they should.
-
Managing risk and realising ESG opportunities
Assess and assure risk and opportunities across ESG with an expert, commercial and pragmatic approach.
-
Project, programme, and portfolio assurance
Successfully delivering projects and programmes include preparing for the wider impact on your business.
-
Service organisation controls report
Independent assurance provides confidence to your customers in relation to your services and control environment.
-
Supplier and contract assurance
Clarity around key supplier relationships: focusing on risk, cost, and operational performance.
-
Technology risk services
IT internal audits and technology risk assurance projects that help you manage your technology risks effectively.
-
Capital allowances (tax depreciation)
Advisory and tools to help you realise opportunities in capital allowances.
-
Corporate tax
Helping companies manage corporate tax affairs: delivering actionable guidance to take opportunities and mitigate risk.
-
Employer solutions
We will help you deliver value through your employees, offering pragmatic employer solutions to increasing costs.
-
Indirect tax
Businesses face complex ever changing VAT regimes, guidance and legislation. We can help you navigate these challenges.
-
International tax
Real-world international tax advice to help you navigate a changing global tax landscape.
-
Our approach to tax
We advise clients on tax law in the UK and, where relevant, other jurisdictions.
-
Private tax
Tax experts for entrepreneurs, families and private business. For now and the long term.
-
Real estate tax
Stay ahead of real estate tax changes with holistic, tax-efficient solutions.
-
Research and development tax incentives
We can help you prepare optimised and robust research and development tax claims.
-
Tax dispute resolution
We make it simple to stay compliant and avoid HMRC tax disputes
-
Tax risk management
We work with you to develop effective tax risk management strategies.
-
Skills and training
Get the right support to deliver corporate and vocational training that leads the way in an expanding market.
-
Private education
Insight and guidance for all businesses in the private education sector: from early years to higher education and edtech.
-
Facilities management and property services
Get insight and strategic support to take opportunities that protect resilience and drive UK and international growth.
-
Recruitment
Helping recruitment companies take opportunities to achieve their goals in a market where talent and skills are key.
-
Food and beverage (F&B)
We can help you find the right ingredients for growth in your food and beverage business.
-
Travel, tourism and leisure
Tap into our range of support for travel, tourism and leisure businesses in this period of challenge and change.
-
Retail, e-commerce and consumer products
With multiple challenges and opportunities in the fast-evolving retail sector, make sure you are ready for them.
-
Banking
Our expertise and insight can help you respond positively to long term and emerging issues in the banking sector.
-
Capital markets
2020 is a demanding year for capital markets. Working with you, we're architecting the future of the sector.
-
Insurance
Our experienced expert team brings you technical expertise and insight to guide you through insurance sector challenges.
-
Investment management
Embracing innovation and shaping business models for long-term success.
-
Pensions
Pension provision is an essential issue for employers, and the role of the trustee is becoming increasingly challenging.
-
Pensions
Pension provision is an essential issue for employers, and the role of the trustee is becoming increasingly challenging.
-
Central and devolved government
Helping central and devolved governments deliver change to improve our communities and grow our economies.
-
Infrastructure and transport
Delivering a successful transport or infrastructure project will require you to balance an often complex set of strategic issues.
-
Local government
Helping local government leverage technical and strategic expertise deliver their agendas and improve public services.
-
Regeneration development and housing
We provide commercial and strategic advice to assist your decision making in pursuing your objectives.
-
Health and social care
Sharing insight and knowledge to deliver transformation and improvement to health and social care services.
-
Charities
Supporting you to achieve positive change in the UK charity sector.
-
Education and skills
The education sector has rarely faced more risk or more opportunity to transform. You need to plan for the future.
-
Social housing
We are committed to helping change social housing for the better, and can help you make the most of every opportunity.
-
Technology
We work with dynamic technology companies of all sizes to help them succeed and grow internationally.
-
Telecommunications
Take all opportunities to realise your goals in telecommunications: from business refresh to international expansion.
-
Media
Media companies must stay agile to thrive in today’s highly competitive market – we’re here to support your ambitions.
Summary
We report on a selection of cases from the Tribunals this month, in addition to the indirect tax headlines from the Chancellor’s Spring Budget.
Northumbria Healthcare successfully convinced the Court of Appeal that hospital parking charges should not be subject to VAT. Meanwhile, Morrisons supermarket failed to argue at the First Tier Tribunal that healthy snack bars could benefit from the zero rate.
Two other First Tier Tribunal decisions, Colchester Institute and Monmore Properties, do not appear to have immediate consequences for other taxpayers, but each highlight potential future issues to monitor, in the education and welfare sectors respectively.
Finally, at the Court of Justice in the European Union, the Advocate General has provided an opinion which may have potential to widen the scope of VAT exemption for investment management services in relation to certain types of DB pension scheme.
Spring Budget 2024
Aside from a headline increase in the VAT registration threshold, there were no significant VAT surprises in the Budget. A number of ongoing consultations were referred to in niche areas (such as retail export scheme; private hire vehicles, carbon credits and DIY housebuilders). Taxpayers for whom these issues are relevant should look out for further updates as the year progresses. There was also a minor change to rules allowing HMRC to offset VAT errors in the same VAT period for the purposes of calculating entitlement to repayment interest.
Regarding customs duty and excise, there were announcements on freezing of fuel duty and alcohol duty rates, uprating of air passenger duty rates, and an upcoming change to the alcohol duty stamps scheme. There are also new duty rates for vaping products and a rise in tobacco duty. Finally, there was confirmation of a prior announcement on a UK carbon border adjustment mechanism (“CBAM”) from 1 January 2027 which will apply to relevant goods imported in the aluminium, cement, ceramics, fertiliser, glass, hydrogen and iron & steel sectors.
News from the UK Courts and Tribunals
Court of Appeal
Northumbria Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust [2024] EWCA Civ 177
This case concerned hospital car parking charges at healthcare sites operated by NHS foundation trusts, in situations where the trust operates car parks itself (ie there is no outsourcing to a third-party operator). The Court found that this income was generated in the course of an activity engaged in by the trusts “as public authorities” – in particular because the provision of parking by the trusts was subject to specific legal conditions in the form of “Parking Principles” issued by the Department of Health. Consequently, this income was found not to be subject to VAT. Furthermore, HMRC had failed to evidence that this VAT treatment would lead to significant distortions of competition in the market for parking.
Comment: while the quantum of this dispute is quite small, there are circa 50 cases standing behind it, with around £70million at stake. NHS Foundation Trusts with a similar factual position will therefore seek significant VAT repayments in due course.
First Tier Tribunal
Wm Morrison Supermarkets Plc [2024] UKFTT 00181 (TC) TC09095
The decision concerns “Nakd” and “Organix” snack bars, which were marketed as healthy, and do not contain ingredients associated with traditional confectionery, namely cane sugar, butter or flour. This case had previously been considered at the First Tier and Upper Tribunals, before being remitted back to the First Tier Tribunal, specifically to consider the relevance of the healthy marketing and non-traditional ingredients. These products included fruit and nut bars; bars that emulate desserts, biscuits or cakes; crunch bars; and bars that emulate sweets or chocolate products.
While “cakes” are zero rated for UK VAT purposes, “confectionery” is standard rated. This case considered the appropriate definitions of these two categories, noting “confectionery” means food items that:
- have been produced by a process of mixing or compounding (but not necessarily cooking) the ingredients;
- taste sweet, either as a result of the inherent sweetness of one or more ingredients or as a result of the addition of sweetening, and whether or not they also taste bitter, salty, sour or spicy; and
- are normally eaten with the fingers in small quantities as a snack or a treat and not as a main meal or part of one.
The Tribunal considered that importance of the look, feel and taste of the Products outweighs any other factors that might suggest that they are not confectionery, and furthermore decided that the taste, texture, mouthfeel and appearance of the products are wholly different from what it considered to be the nearest “cake comparator” (a dark fruit cake).
Consequently, the products under appeal were found to be standard rated.
Comment: the boundaries of the zero rate for food remain one of the most complex and contentious areas of UK VAT law. This decision highlights the significant potential for uncertainty, and may call into question historical application of the zero rate to a variety of other similar products. Retailers and manufacturers should carefully review product portfolios to identify whether any additional VAT liability is likely to arise; and should monitor whether this decision is appealed further in due course.
Colchester Institute Corporation (No. 2) - TC09097
This case related to an output VAT assessment raised by HMRC under the “Lennartz” VAT accounting rules for “non-business” use of input VAT, in relation to costs of a building development used to provide education and/or vocational training free of charge to students but funded by grants from government agencies. This came further to a previous Upper Tribunal decision for the same taxpayer, which had already found that the College made only “business” income for VAT purposes (which was VAT-exempt), rather than “non-business” income.
The First Tier Tribunal was bound by the previous Upper Tribunal decision, and therefore unsurprisingly found that the college was only making “business” supplies, such that the output tax assessment was not due.
Comment: to date, HMRC has seemingly not applied the outcome of the previous Upper Tribunal decision to other taxpayers, many of whom consider similar income to be “non-business” for VAT purposes. It remains to be seen whether this latest decision will be appealed. There is potential that this case may prompt a future change in HMRC policy, which could have adverse implications for taxpayers currently relying on “non-business” status to access other VAT reliefs.
Monmore Properties Limited - TC09072
This was an appeal by a care home group that includes both a “state-regulated” entity and a non-regulated entity. The group provides welfare services both to Local Authority funded residents and to privately funded residents and was subject to VAT assessment by HMRC. The FTT decided some of the assessments were made out of time. Meanwhile the Tribunal noted that there is a wider dispute in these proceedings as to which of the group companies supplied the welfare services, and when, but that is a matter for the substantive appeal which is yet to be heard.
Comment: while this latest decision only relates to time limits which are specific to this one taxpayer, the outstanding questions to be heard at subsequent appeal may be of interest to a wide variety of welfare businesses, especially those which have implemented, or are considering implementing VAT efficient structures with the use of non-state regulated entities.
This structure typically involves the creation of a separate non-regulated company in a VAT group with the state-regulated care companies. The new company will contract directly with Local Authorities / Clinical Commissioning Groups and NHS bodies for the provision of welfare services. These services would be standard rated for VAT purposes, thus enabling a proportion of input VAT recovery, whilst the delivery of the underlying welfare services continues to be performed by the existing regulated care company under subcontract within the VAT group.
The results of the substantive appeal and the question as to whether or not services were supplied by a state-regulated entity, or by an unregulated entity, is fundamental to the VAT treatment of the group’s income (either as taxable or exempt for VAT purposes); and consequently has the potential to have a significant impact on input VAT recovery entitlement.
Court of Justice of the European Union
Joined Cases C‑639/22 to C‑644/22 — Opinion - Netherlands
These cases concern the VAT liability of the services of managing various occupational pension funds in the Netherlands. The funds in question appear to be consistent with what would be called a “defined benefit” scheme in the UK, which is to say, the level of the pension entitlements and benefits depends primarily on the level of employment income and years of service.
Previous VAT law has established that the VAT exemption for management of “special investment funds” applies only where (amongst other conditions) the pension customers bear an investment risk. In the UK this has therefore limited the VAT exemption to management of defined contribution schemes, and not to defined benefit schemes. This case considers whether the existence of mechanisms to reduce or increase pension entitlements in response to investment performance of a defined benefit scheme constitutes a comparable investment risk, sufficient to allow these pension funds to be treated as special investment funds.
The Advocate General has indicated that the Court of Justice should answer this question by considering whether the pension commitment provides primarily for guaranteed benefits, or otherwise for benefits dependent on the performance of the invested capital. The taxpayer has also put forward an alternative argument based on “fiscal neutrality” by comparison to certain other pensions in the Netherlands which already benefit from “special investment fund” status.
Comment: this is the latest on the long line of cases defining the limits of exemption for management of special investment funds. Currently, UK Defined Benefit pension funds typically suffer a degree of irrecoverable VAT on management related costs, and therefore any potential to minimise the incidence of VAT will be of interest to the sector. It remains to be seen whether the Court of Justice will follow the Advocate General’s opinion, and if so, the extent to which this may benefit any particular Defined Benefit pension scheme may be fact sensitive. It remains to be seen what impact this may have on UK law given the implementation of the The Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act from 1 January 2024. In the meantime, there are various other means by which to mitigate irrecoverable VAT in UK Defined Benefit pension schemes which should be considered regardless of the outcome of this case.
Other News
Revenue & Customs Brief 1/2024 — Live Web Streaming of Funeral Services
On 1 March 2024, HMRC published a Revenue & Customs Brief (1/2024) on live web streaming of funeral services, clarifying HMRC’s position that live web streaming of funeral, burial or cremation services is VAT exempt under VATA 1994, Sch 9, Grp 8, Item 2.