Article

Before you make an acquisition: When should diligence start?

By: Debbie Mayor

Founders agree a price on a handshake, ‘subject to diligence’. With the timetable set, momentum builds, everyone is focused on getting the deal done, however insufficient consideration of diligence findings means any risk that's missed before completion becomes yours on day one.
Contents

Debbie Mayor, Partner in Grant Thornton UK's Transaction Advisory Services team, explains why diligence is a strategic tool for founders and why it works best when it starts early.

Buying is the faster route to scale

Acquisitions aren't for everyone and plenty of founders are happy to grow organically. If you want scale or a bigger footprint quickly, buying is the faster route, as long as funding is there. That funding might come from private equity backing a buy-and-build or from a corporate with cash on its balance sheet.

Why diligence works best early

Picture the week after you agree the deal, when you've met the target and shaken hands on the headlines and settled on a price. The momentum feels so good that diligence can start to look like a tick-box exercise on the way to completion.

I'd ask you to see it another way. Diligence sits on your side of the table and tests whether the financials support the price. The value is in the findings, and only if you have time to act on them. That is why diligence needs to start early. A report that lands days before you sign leaves no room to change the price or ask for stronger protections. 

The trap of agreeing first

The trap is a timetable that has already been set. Buyers often arrive with the deal agreed and say they need the diligence done by the end of the month. By then the target isn't ready and the information isn't there.

A second trap is looking at revenue first, which is understandable. Strong revenue growth doesn't guarantee strong earnings because costs can go unaccounted for and cash generation can tell a different story. Quality of earnings means how much of the reported profit reflects true sustainable performance. It is what diligence is built to test, so I'd encourage you to look beyond the top line.

What it costs once you complete

The financial cost of a missed issue is usually overpaying, because earnings that looked solid in the sales process don't stand up once someone tests them. The commercial cost shows up when a big customer has been lost without anyone mentioning it, and you find yourself asking where the revenue will come from.

What early advice can change

Two clients show how much timing changes the outcome. The first was an energy services business weighing up a UK target with similar services. The deal would widen their footprint and bring customers they don't reach today, so understanding revenue by customer and the contracts was a priority. They involved us early, prioritising the customer analysis, where we found a significant contract had recently been lost. This directly impact the assessment of sustainable earnings, and having identified this issue quickly allowed our client to renegotiate the deal early before the deal gathered pace. 

The second client asked us to carry out diligence on a target. Early in the work we found an issue with how the target recognised its revenue. The client hadn't known about it when they agreed the original heads of terms, the outline terms set before diligence began. Correcting the accounting treatment changed the numbers and moved the price, given how the deal was structured. The client renegotiated early and paid less for the business.

There's never a good time to reopen a price, but late is the hardest. Had the issue surfaced close to completion, the client would have been renegotiating with a target who hadn't seen it coming. Without the work they would have overpaid.

Four things to settle before you agree a price

If you came to me before you'd agreed anything I'd suggest we run through four things in order. 

  1. First, I'd ask how the acquisition supports your growth strategy and what you want it to deliver, because a clear answer gives you something to measure everything else against.
  2. Second, I'd ask whether you understand why the business earns what it earns. If anything in your conversations with the target has made you uneasy, whether that's a customer or the cost base, then that is where diligence should begin and your instincts are an early brief.
  3. Third, I'd work backwards from your completion date. Some founders spend two years talking to a target before they proceed. Others are in a competitive process that needs diligence done in four weeks, and a buy-side process won't usually take less than that.
  4. Finally, have you agreed with the target how diligence will run, and who is guiding you through it? Many founders are doing this for the first time, so being well advised matters. Bringing in a diligence advisor at the right time lets you plan the process and focus on the key risk areas.

There will be issues in any acquisition. What matters is finding them before completion, so that you go in knowing what you're buying and with the protections you need. A good process gives you the evidence to proceed on the right terms. It also leaves room to reshape the deal or walk away if there's a clear reason.

The handshake agrees a price. Diligence tells you whether it's the right one.

Weighing up an acquisition, or close to a handshake already? Join PerfectTed co-founder Levi Levenfiche and our specialists on 24 November to hear which growth decisions are worth getting right first time.

Register for the webinar now.