Beyond the checklist: why culture is the real test of Best Value
Best Value duty: why culture is the real test for councils. Our response to the government's consultation on revised guidance, and how to spot problems early.
By: Rob Turner, Joanna Norton
17 Nov 2026 3 min read

The Prime Minister has pledged “good growth in every postcode”, and the government’s Rewiring the State statement sets out plans for every part of England to be covered by a strategic authority by the end of 2028. Our report asks what that ambition means for the 39 county areas CCN represents – home to 47% of England’s population and 39% of its economic output, worth £824 billion in 2023.
On most measures, county areas carry more of the national economy than any other group of places, but they’ve grown more slowly. Between 2013 and 2023, county output grew by 14.7% in real terms, against 17.2% for England as a whole. Had county areas kept pace, their output in 2023 would have been around £19 billion higher. Their scale also makes them central to national growth: a percentage point of growth across county areas is worth more than a point of growth in any single city-region – London included.
The gap isn’t a lack of jobs or ambition. County labour markets have the highest employment rate and the lowest economic inactivity of any type of area, and county areas delivered over half of England’s net additional homes in 2024/25. What holds them back is structural:
These constraints aren’t evenly spread: Surrey’s challenge isn’t Cumberland’s, and Cornwall’s economy isn’t Hertfordshire’s. So the report sets out five example typologies – spatial character, economic role, sectoral specialisation, economic function and resilience – as a practical way for government to tell county areas apart, with a worked example allocating all 39 areas by spatial character.
It concludes with 10 recommendations across four themes: investment, strategic, tactical and technical. They include giving county areas a route into Local Growth Plans and a genuine growth financial settlement, prioritising infrastructure investment, making strategic planning work across boundaries, and updating the Green Book so it properly values dispersed, polycentric and rural economies.
If you’d like to discuss what the findings mean for your area – including where it sits in the typologies and what that might means for your growth plans – or to request a tailored data pack comparing your area on growth, public transport access, skills and digital connectivity, get in touch with Rob Turner.
Best Value duty: why culture is the real test for councils. Our response to the government's consultation on revised guidance, and how to spot problems early.
National Care Service reform: what it means for councils and NHS partners, from funding pressures to joining up care, health, housing and communities.
Local government reorganisation inherits budget gaps, savings risk and debt. How new unitary authorities can plan for the financial challenge ahead.
This series brings together our experts with thought leaders to discuss the key issues, updates, and events relevant for the public sector.